Safe to say Jim Hiller isn't off to the greatest start as the Toronto Maple Leafs' new head coach.
From the team's ongoing losing streak (they at least won a point) to the mis-utilization of Gavin McKenna (can the Leafs please loan him to Team Canada for the World Juniors? I'm asking nicely) there has been another healthier-than-normal meltdown surrounding hockey's equivalent of dark matter to start the season.
But just as his career in Toronto is getting off to a rocky start, it might be coming to a dismal end. Sources indicate that Hiller will be canned by the end of the weekend, with ex-Vancouver Canucks bench boss Bruce Boudreau lined up as the successor.
Imagine if the Leafs hire John Tortorella.
Even then, the news really does give the feeling that, regardless of who the coach is going forward, there will be a new face behind the bench next season. Unless whoever the Leafs appoint does the unlikely and gets them into the playoffs and then propels them on an even-unlikelier run to the Conference Finals, it's almost certain that more money will be thrown at the generally-non-issue that is the Leafs' coaching.
If the Leafs wanted to simply save face and start again to some capacity, then Edmonton Oilers assistant head coach D.J. Smith is their candidate.
D.J. Smith's coaching journey could take him back to Toronto
Say what you will about Hiller being part of the problem to open the season, but there are way too many explanations that all could justify why the current iteration of the Leafs constantly underachieves.
After starting his NHL coaching career under the tutelage of Mike Babcock in Toronto, Smith became the head coach of the Ottawa Senators. Despite the criticism, the slow starts, and the "Fire D.J." chants, one has to credit Smith to some capacity. He helped guide the Senators through a rebuild and back towards being a competitive hockey club by being aware of the needs of his prospects, particularly given the team's place in the standings.
He also echoed the ethos of his now-two-time mentor, one that has helped get the Oilers to where they are right now, by making sure that his team came to play every night and that there was a team-first mentality across the entire organization.
The problem was that his approach stalled at one of the final hurdles. During the 2022-23 campaign, the Sens were in the playoff race until the final weeks. But the team couldn't replicate that form to start the following season, and Smith lost his job as a result.
Smith's two-year run as an assistant coach with the Los Angeles Kings included a 2024-25 campaign where the Kings' goaltending unit helped establish the team as a true playoff contender. But after taking a 2-0 series lead against the Edmonton Oilers, the Kings proceeded to lose the next four games and another first round series.
Smith was promoted to interim head coach late in the 2025-26 season, guided the Kings through their offensive struggles, and got them into the playoffs. That said, they were swept in what was a quasi-competitive series against the Colorado Avalanche.
Though Smith was in the conversation to become the team's next head coach, he ultimately ended up reuniting with Babcock in Edmonton. Peter Laviolette ended up taking on the position, though he is off to a 7-11-2 start with the team.
Since returning to the assistant coach role, Smith has gotten a golden opportunity to learn what it takes to lead a hockey club that is consistently seen as both a playoff and Stanley Cup contender. After all, Babcock's Oilers are off to a 17-4-3 start to the season and would be on pace for the best regular-season finish of the Connor McDavid era.
Why Smith would be a logical fit for the Leafs
Hiller might not be formally sacked, but it's reasonable to assume that major change is coming for the Leafs.
After all, it's been a decade of whatever they've been trying to pull off. Minus a few too many major cap hits and just two series wins, they're more or less right back where they were to start this whole initiative.
But while Babcock and Smith weren't able to get the Leafs any further than the first round, the issues that have plagued the team now and in the past clearly extend beyond their knowledge of the game.
What's more is that mine and anyone else's knowledge of the game also isn't enough to understand the team's mentality. All I know is that they want to extend beyond the jersey business, but efforts at expansion have clearly been quite tough.
I thought they weren’t here to sell jerseys 😂 😂 pic.twitter.com/K6j6jMEsTe
— Drew Livingstone (@ProducerDrew_) November 20, 2026
So did I, Producer Drew.
But while MLSE says they don't want to just sell jerseys that get thrown back onto the ice, Smith will actually not settle for jersey sales and moral victories.
While someone like Boudreau or Tortorella will bring a winning pedigree to the table, Smith can at least match that with his mentality. No matter if the Leafs opt to rebuild or try to change the leadership cast, Smith can bring things back to the basics and make it about the team, not just the individual player.
If Auston Matthews, William Nylander, Morgan Rielly, and John Tavares left, Smith would have a group highlighted by McKenna and Easton Cowan. We've seen Smith succeed at developing prospects and players in this fashion during his time in Ottawa, so this would not be unfamiliar territory for him.
Yes, there are situations where Babcock and his coaching staff have had to field superstars like McDavid and Leon Draisaitl more often than they should. Yes, them and Evan Bouchard happen to lead the team in points.
But navigating these decisions is part of what coaching the Oilers entails. It's also part of what coaching any superstar-led team entails.
What's clear is that the mentality Babcock and Smith share still works here; though one must recognize that they contrast to some capacity, the reactions are similar. The players backed the move to hire Babcock in the first place, and they've since bought into the team-first approach that, around the league, is loved by some and hated by others.
Smith brings a little more of a positive demeanor and less of a role-focused approach to that mentality, particularly when it comes to replicating his mentor's ability, albeit controversial, to communicate and work with players. Even then, he still works to get players to buy in and work together to ensure the team's success.
Vasily Podkolzin standing up for McDavid after he got hit by Drew Helleson? A prime example of this.
The fact that the team hasn't (visibly) fallen to internal chaos even with the superstar scoring remaining constant should speak volumes about Babcock and Smith's ability to keep depth players involved and give everyone the chance to pitch in for the team's success.
Tthe last time Smith left a head coaching role, he took full advantage of his opportunity to learn and to help a head coach lead their own lineup. The fact that the Leafs, Kings, and Oilers all benefitted from Smith's work in this respect speaks volumes to his once-more-renewed potential as a head coach
To end on a personal note
I didn't like the way the Sens were progressing up the standings under Smith. They needed to get from Point A (learning to win) to Point B (being a playoff team), and the current structure wasn't enabling that to happen in a way that their current head coach, Travis Green, has been able to achieve.
But the Sens stuck with him and his mentality to the final day, and that's something worthy of respect.
They did so without much question, if at all.
As I look back on Smith's work getting Ottawa out of their rebuild and his ability to guide the Kings into the playoffs when that looked a relative-uncertainty, I've grown to respect his coaching style and the fact that sometimes the best coaches aren't necessarily the ones with the best records. Or the best roster situations.
You need someone who knows how to build and work with the best possible roster. That roster is one that both plays to the sum of its parts and as a whole.
Last year's Kings team was essentially a veteran-loaded lineup; some good, some not-so-good-anymore. There were some young pieces here and there in addition to good-at-times goaltending.
They still made the playoffs.
Smith has to get credit for that.
The Leafs right now are a team mired in a bad situation, one that has consistently lowered their chances at winning a Stanley Cup.
No matter if the organization triggers a revamp, Smith can right the ship.
He's proven it once before in Toronto. After that, he did so in Ottawa, in Los Angeles, and now in Edmonton.
Should the Leafs give him the chance, history suggests that he will take it.
