5 Players The Edmonton Oilers Should Try to Pry From The Pittsburgh Penguins at the Deadline?

The Pittsburgh Penguins are unlikely to make the playoff, if they choose to be sellers at the deadline, the Edmonton Oilers should be buyers.

Feb 15, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins forward Sidney Crosby (87) celebrates
Feb 15, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins forward Sidney Crosby (87) celebrates / Jamie Sabau-USA TODAY Sports
4 of 6
Next

As the NHL trade deadline looms, teams across the league are evaluating their rosters, strengths, and weaknesses in hopes of making strategic moves to improve their chances of success. Among those teams are the Edmonton Oilers, a team that has high hopes this season of finally lift the Stanley Cup at the end of the season.

On the other side of the spectrum are the Pittsburgh Penguins, a perennial contender known for their ability to reload and compete at a high level year after year. This year though the Penguins stars are starting to show their age and it looks like they will miss the playoffs.

With both teams heading in different directions this season, the question arises: Is it time for the Edmonton Oilers to attempt to pick apart the Pittsburgh Penguins at the trade deadline?

Assessing the Situation

Before delving into whether the Oilers should target the Penguins, it's essential to assess the current state of both teams. The Oilers, led by superstar forwards Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, are two of the best players in the NHL, so there should be no issue that scoring is no issue. Despite their offensive firepower, the team has faced challenges in keeping the puck out of their own net, with goaltending and defensive issues plaguing them at times.

Meanwhile, the Penguins have continued to be a force in the Eastern Conference, boasting a roster filled with talent and experience. Led by Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, the Penguins have consistently found ways to compete at a high level. However, as their key players age it appears the Penguins' championship window may be closing.

Identifying Areas of Need

To determine whether the Oilers should target the Penguins at the trade deadline, it's crucial to identify areas of need for both teams. For Edmonton, shoring up their defensive and forward depth and goaltending could be a priority, as improving their ability to prevent goals would greatly enhance their chances of success. Also, if the Oilers can land a top 6 winger that would also be a plus.

On the other hand, the Penguins may be looking to add young talent and prospects to replenish their system and prepare for the future. If they are willing to move out some of their superstar players, they will be looking for pieces to help the future.

Dec 8, 2023; Sunrise, Florida, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins left wing Jake Guentzel (59)
Dec 8, 2023; Sunrise, Florida, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins left wing Jake Guentzel (59) / Sam Navarro-USA TODAY Sports

Potential Trade Targets

Jake Guentzel

Jake Guentzel, the talented forward of the Pittsburgh Penguins, could be a perfect addition to the Edmonton Oilers roster. The Oilers, perennial contenders in the NHL, could greatly benefit from Guentzel's skill set and versatility.

First and foremost, Guentzel brings scoring prowess to the table. He has consistently proven himself as a reliable goal-scorer, capable of finding the back of the net in various situations. His ability to finish plays, coupled with his hockey IQ, would provide the Oilers with an additional offensive threat to complement their star players like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. Guentzel's offensive instincts would undoubtedly thrive playing alongside such dynamic talents, creating a potent offensive trio that would be challenging for any opposing team to contain.

Moreover, Guentzel's playoff experience would be invaluable to the Oilers, especially in their pursuit of postseason success. He has a knack for elevating his game when it matters most, as evidenced by his impressive performances in the playoffs, including his standout performance during the Penguins' Stanley Cup run in 2017. His ability to perform under pressure and deliver clutch goals would provide the Oilers with a significant boost in high-stakes situations.

Additionally, Guentzel's versatility would offer the Oilers flexibility in their lineup configurations. Whether deployed as a top-line winger or slotting into a secondary-scoring role, Guentzel has showcased the adaptability to excel in various situations. This flexibility would allow Oilers head coach to experiment with different line combinations and optimize the team's offensive output.

Furthermore, Guentzel's work ethic and competitiveness make him a perfect fit for the Oilers' culture. Known for his relentless drive and determination on the ice, Guentzel embodies the blue-collar mentality that resonates with Edmonton's passionate fan base. His commitment to his craft and willingness to do whatever it takes to help his team win would make him a beloved figure in Oil Country.

Jake Guentzel would be an excellent fit for the Edmonton Oilers due to his scoring ability, playoff experience, versatility, and work ethic. His addition would bolster the team's offensive firepower and provide them with a significant boost in their quest for postseason success.

An issue with Guentzel though, is that he is currently injured and not slated to come back till shortly after the trade deadline. This could make the cost to acquire him a lot lower though.

Feb 10, 2024; Winnipeg, Manitoba, CAN;  Pittsburgh Penguins forward Sidney Crosby (87)
Feb 10, 2024; Winnipeg, Manitoba, CAN; Pittsburgh Penguins forward Sidney Crosby (87) / Terrence Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Sidney Crosby

Sidney Crosby, the legendary captain of the Pittsburgh Penguins, would undoubtedly be a transformative addition to the Edmonton Oilers roster. Widely regarded as one of the greatest hockey players of all time, Crosby's presence alone would significantly elevate the Oilers' chances of success on multiple fronts.

With the Penguins potentially rebuilding Crosby would no doubt be the piece that would bring in the greatest return. A trade involving Crosby would first need Crosby’s approval, but if winning another cup is on his list the Oilers would be a good landing spot.

Firstly, Crosby brings unparalleled skill and leadership to any team he joins. As a three-time Stanley Cup champion, two-time Olympic gold medalist, and multiple-time recipient of the Hart Memorial Trophy as the league's most valuable player, Crosby's resume speaks for itself. His on-ice vision, playmaking ability, and scoring touch would immediately bolster the Oilers' offense, providing them with a dynamic presence down the middle that no team could match. Furthermore, Crosby's leadership qualities would be invaluable in guiding and inspiring his teammates, particularly the younger players on the Oilers roster.

Additionally, Crosby's experience and poise in high-pressure situations would be a game-changer for the Oilers, especially in the playoffs. Throughout his illustrious career, Crosby has consistently delivered clutch performances when it matters most, earning him the reputation as a big-game player. His ability to rise to the occasion and lead by example would provide the Oilers with a significant advantage in tight playoff matchups, where every goal and every shift can make a difference.

Moreover, Crosby's work ethic and dedication to his craft are second to none. Known for his relentless commitment to improvement and his meticulous attention to detail, Crosby sets the standard for professionalism in the NHL. His influence in the locker room would foster a culture of accountability and excellence, pushing the Oilers to strive for greatness on a daily basis.

Furthermore, Crosby's off-ice presence would also benefit the Oilers organization as a whole. His reputation as a role model and ambassador for the sport would undoubtedly help raise the profile of the team and attract additional talent and sponsorship opportunities.

Sidney Crosby would be a transformative addition to the Edmonton Oilers, bringing unmatched skill, leadership, and experience to the team. His presence would elevate the Oilers' performance on the ice, inspire his teammates to new heights, and help establish a winning culture that could lead to sustained success for years to come.

Jan 22, 2024; Tempe, Arizona, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins center Evgeni Malkin (71)
Jan 22, 2024; Tempe, Arizona, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins center Evgeni Malkin (71) / Rick Scuteri-USA TODAY Sports

Evgeni Malkin

Evgeni Malkin, another dynamic center of the Pittsburgh Penguins, would be an exceptional addition to the Edmonton Oilers roster. Malkin's combination of size, skill, and hockey IQ made him one of the most dominant players in the NHL, and his presence would have a profound impact on the Oilers' lineup.

Firstly, Malkin's scoring ability would provide a significant boost to the Oilers' offense. A perennial point-producer, Malkin has consistently been among the league leaders in goals and assists throughout his career. His lethal shot, playmaking vision, and ability to control the pace of the game would make him a formidable offensive weapon for the Oilers, complementing the talents of Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.

Moreover, Malkin's experience and leadership would be invaluable assets to the Oilers, particularly in the playoffs. As a three-time Stanley Cup champion and former Conn Smythe Trophy winner, Malkin knows what it takes to win at the highest level. His playoff pedigree and ability to elevate his game in crucial moments would provide the Oilers with a reliable scoring threat when it matters most, giving them a better chance to succeed in the postseason.

Additionally, Malkin's versatility would give the Oilers more flexibility in their lineup combinations. Whether playing alongside McDavid and Draisaitl on the top line or anchoring his own line, Malkin's ability to adapt to different roles and situations would make him a valuable asset for Oilers head coach to utilize.

Furthermore, Malkin's physical presence and two-way game would add depth to the Oilers' lineup. Despite his offensive prowess, Malkin is also known for his strong defensive play and ability to win battles along the boards. His willingness to compete in all areas of the ice would set a positive example for his teammates and help the Oilers become a more well-rounded team.

In conclusion, Evgeni Malkin would be an exceptional addition to the Edmonton Oilers roster, bringing scoring ability, playoff experience, leadership, versatility, and a strong two-way game to the team. His presence would elevate the Oilers' performance on both ends of the ice and give them a better chance to compete for the Stanley Cup.

Jan 15, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Tristan Jarry (35)
Jan 15, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins goaltender Tristan Jarry (35) / Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Tristan Jarry

Tristan Jarry, the talented goaltender for the Pittsburgh Penguins, could potentially be a solid addition to the Edmonton Oilers' roster. As the Oilers seek to solidify their goaltending position and bolster their defensive stability, Jarry presents several qualities that could address these needs.

Firstly, Jarry has demonstrated significant growth and potential during his time with the Penguins. Despite facing some challenges early in his career, Jarry has shown resilience and improvement, eventually establishing himself as a reliable option between the pipes for Pittsburgh. His ability to bounce back from adversity and continue to refine his game suggests that he has the mental toughness and determination necessary to succeed in high-pressure situations—a trait particularly valuable for a goaltender in the NHL.

Furthermore, Jarry's technical skills and athleticism make him a formidable presence in the net. His quick reflexes, solid positioning, and ability to track the puck effectively allow him to make key saves and keep his team in games. While consistency has been a focus for Jarry, his overall skill set suggests that with the right support and coaching, he could develop into a top-tier goaltender capable of stealing games for his team.

Additionally, Jarry's relatively young age, 28, means that he likely has his best years ahead of him. Acquiring a goaltender with Jarry's potential could provide the Oilers with stability in net for years to come, offering them a long-term solution to their goaltending needs and could be a duo with Skinner for years to come.

Moreover, bringing in a goaltender like Jarry could also provide healthy competition and depth in the goaltending position for the Oilers. Competition often brings out the best in players, and having multiple capable goaltenders vying for playing time could push each goaltender to elevate their game and perform at their highest level.

In conclusion, Tristan Jarry could be a promising addition to the Edmonton Oilers' roster, offering them a young goaltender with significant upside and the potential to solidify their goaltending position for the long term. While there may be areas for improvement in his game, Jarry's growth trajectory and skill set make him a compelling option for the Oilers as they look to bolster their roster and compete for postseason success.

Jan 27, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA;  Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Kris Letang (58)
Jan 27, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Kris Letang (58) / Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Kris Letang

Kris Letang, the skilled defenseman of the Pittsburgh Penguins, would be a great veteran addition to the Edmonton Oilers' roster. Letang's combination of offensive prowess, defensive reliability, and experience make him one of the most coveted blueliners in the NHL, and his addition could significantly bolster the Oilers' defensive corps.

Firstly, Letang's offensive contributions would add a new dimension to the Oilers' blue line. Known for his exceptional puck-moving abilities, Letang is adept at initiating the transition game and creating scoring opportunities for his teammates. His ability to quarterback the power play and generate offense from the back end would provide the Oilers with an additional scoring threat and help alleviate some of the pressure on their forwards to produce points.

Moreover, Letang's defensive acumen should not be overlooked. While he is often recognized for his offensive skills, Letang is also a reliable presence in his own end of the ice. His strong skating, active stick, and hockey intelligence enable him to effectively break up plays, suppress scoring chances, and contribute to his team's defensive efforts. Letang's two-way capabilities would provide the Oilers with stability on the blue line and help mitigate opponents' offensive attacks.

Additionally, Letang's experience and leadership would be invaluable assets to the Oilers, particularly as they aim to contend for the Stanley Cup. As a three-time Stanley Cup champion and a veteran presence in the league, Letang understands what it takes to succeed at the highest level. His postseason experience and ability to perform under pressure would provide the Oilers with a valuable voice in the locker room and help guide their younger defensive players through the rigors of playoff hockey.

Furthermore, Letang's versatility would offer the Oilers flexibility in their defensive pairings and lineup configurations. Whether deployed as a top-pairing defenseman alongside a stay-at-home partner or utilized in a more offensive-minded role, Letang has the skill set and adaptability to excel in various situations, giving Oilers head coach multiple options to optimize the team's defensive performance.

In conclusion, Kris Letang would be an exceptional addition to the Edmonton Oilers' roster, providing them with a dynamic defenseman capable of making significant contributions at both ends of the ice. His offensive creativity, defensive reliability, postseason experience, and leadership qualities would make him a valuable asset as the Oilers seek to solidify their roster and contend for championships.

NEXT. 3 reasons why the Edmonton Oilers must make a serious push for Adam Henrique. 3 reasons why the Edmonton Oilers must make a serious push for Adam Henrique. dark

For any of these moves to even become a reality, the Pittsburg Penguins will need to be out of the playoff race at the time of the deadline. Currently 5 points out of the final wildcard spot that is a reality. Even if they are out all these players have some sort of no movement clause. If they want to come to the Oilers will ultimately come down to whether they want to come or not. Even though these scenarios are unlikely there is still a chance. I didn't think Holland could get Ekholm and he did that...

feed

Next