3 trades we are glad the Edmonton Oilers avoided at the deadline

Explore the three potential trades the Oilers sidestepped at the trade deadline.

Pittsburgh Penguins v Minnesota Wild
Pittsburgh Penguins v Minnesota Wild / Nick Wosika/GettyImages
3 of 4
Next
Edmonton Oilers Celebrate Win
Edmonton Oilers Celebrate Win / Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports

As the dust settles after the NHL trade deadline, the league's landscape shifts once again, with teams positioning themselves for the final push toward the playoffs. Amongst the flurry of deals and maneuvers, the Edmonton Oilers stand as a notable figure, having navigated the trade deadline waters with both intent and caution.

For Oilers fans, the anticipation leading up to the deadline was palpable. With hopes high and expectations soaring, there was a sense of urgency surrounding the team's actions. Would they make significant moves to bolster their lineup for a playoff run, or would they opt for a more conservative approach, maintaining the status quo?

In the end, the Oilers found themselves somewhere in between. While they were active participants in the trade market, they opted against certain deals that could have significantly altered their trajectory. And in hindsight, these decisions may have been for the best.

One of the most talked-about aspects of the Oilers' trade deadline approach was their reluctance to part ways with key assets. Despite rumours swirling around potential blockbuster deals, the Oilers held firm, unwilling to mortgage their future for short-term gains. This prudent approach may have disappointed some fans hungry for immediate improvements, but it speaks to the organization's commitment to long-term success.

Moreover, the trades that the Oilers did not make may have been just as impactful as the ones they did. In a league where every move is scrutinized and dissected, sometimes the best deals are the ones you avoid. Whether it was resisting the temptation to overpay for a rental player or standing pat with their current roster, the Oilers demonstrated a level of restraint and discernment that bodes well for their future.

Of course, the true measure of the Oilers' trade deadline performance will be determined on the ice. As they gear up for the playoff push, the team will rely on the talent and chemistry they've cultivated throughout the season. While other teams may have made bigger splashes at the deadline, the Oilers are betting on the strength of their core group to carry them through.

In the end, the trade deadline serves as a reminder of the delicate balance teams must strike between short-term success and long-term sustainability. For the Edmonton Oilers, their approach may not have garnered the same headlines as some of their counterparts, but it reflects a calculated strategy aimed at building a championship-caliber team for years to come.

Carolina Hurricanes left wing Jake Guentzel (59)
Carolina Hurricanes left wing Jake Guentzel (59) / James Guillory-USA TODAY Sports

Avoiding the need to add Guentzel

Edmonton Oilers fans are known for their passionate enthusiasm, especially when it comes to their team's success. With two superstars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl leading the charge, the desire for additional firepower in the top six has been a recurring theme among fans and analysts alike.

One name that frequently surfaced in trade discussions was Jake Guentzel of the Pittsburgh Penguins. Known for his scoring prowess and ability to make an impact in crucial moments, Guentzel seemed like an ideal fit to complement the Oilers' dynamic duo.

The allure of adding a player of Guentzel's caliber to the Oilers' roster was undeniable. His ability to generate offense and create scoring opportunities would have provided a significant boost to Edmonton's forward lines, potentially elevating the team's offensive output to new heights.

However, as enticing as the prospect of acquiring Guentzel may have been, the reality of the situation was far more complex. With Guentzel set to become a free agent at the end of the season, the asking price for his services was undoubtedly steep.

For Oilers management, the decision to pursue Guentzel involved weighing the short-term benefits against the long-term implications. While adding him to the roster could have provided an immediate boost to the team's playoff aspirations, it also carried inherent risks, particularly in terms of the assets that would need to be sacrificed in a trade.

In the end, it appears that caution won out over impulse. Despite the tantalizing possibility of adding Guentzel to their lineup, the Oilers opted to exercise restraint and prioritize the team's long-term interests. While the decision may have disappointed some fans hoping for a blockbuster acquisition, it reflects a prudent approach to roster management.

Furthermore, the uncertainty surrounding Guentzel's future beyond the current season likely factored into the Oilers' decision-making process. With the salary cap landscape and roster dynamics constantly evolving, investing significant assets in a player with an uncertain contractual situation carries inherent risks.

Edmonton Oilers goaltender Stuart Skinner (74)
Edmonton Oilers goaltender Stuart Skinner (74) / Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

Confidence on the goaltending tandem

As the Edmonton Oilers gear up for the playoff push, fans are not only focused on bolstering the team's offensive firepower but also on shoring up the goaltending position. While rising star Stuart Skinner has shown promise between the pipes, concerns about fatigue and the need for a reliable backup have lingered since last season's playoff run.

Calvin Pickard has provided glimpses of brilliance in relief of Skinner, but questions remain about his ability to shoulder a heavier workload, especially in high-stakes playoff matchups. With the memories of Skinner's struggles in the postseason still fresh in fans' minds, the search for a dependable backup goaltender became a priority for many Oilers supporters.

Throughout the season, several netminders were linked to the Oilers in trade rumors, but one name stood out among the rest: Jake Allen of the Montreal Canadiens. With experience as a starter for both the Canadiens and the St. Louis Blues, Allen seemed like the perfect candidate to provide stability and support for Skinner down the stretch.

However, despite the allure of adding a proven veteran like Allen to the roster, the Oilers ultimately opted to place their faith in Skinner and Pickard. This decision speaks volumes about the organization's confidence in their goaltending tandem and their belief that both goaltenders are capable of rising to the occasion when called upon.

While the temptation to make a splashy acquisition at the trade deadline was undoubtedly present, the Oilers chose to prioritize continuity and chemistry over making a drastic change in goal. By sticking with Skinner and Pickard, the Oilers are banking on the duo's familiarity with the team's systems and playing style to carry them through the gruelling playoff grind.

As the Oilers embark on their quest for playoff success, all eyes will be on Skinner and Pickard as they look to prove their doubters wrong and solidify their status as a reliable goaltending tandem. While the decision to pass on a player like Jake Allen may have raised eyebrows among fans, it is a testament to the Oilers' belief in their current roster and their unwavering commitment to their goaltenders.

Ex-Calgary Flames defenseman Chris Tanev (8)
Ex-Calgary Flames defenseman Chris Tanev (8) / John Jones-USA TODAY Sports

The search to upgrade the defense

The Edmonton Oilers are no strangers to the perennial pursuit of defensive upgrades. Whether it's bolstering the goaltending or shoring up the blue line, the quest for defensive stability has been a recurring theme for the team in recent years. Following a savvy trade during last year's deadline that brought in Mattias Ekholm, fans were hopeful for a similar impact acquisition this season to solidify the second pairing.

One name that generated considerable buzz leading up to the deadline was defenseman Chris Tanev of the provincial rival Calgary Flames. Imagining Tanev in Oilers colors sparked intrigue among fans, but the feasibility of such a trade and the potential asking price from the Flames remained uncertain.

The prospect of adding Tanev to the Oilers' defensive corps seemed tantalizing on the surface. Known for his defensive acumen and ability to log significant minutes, Tanev appeared to be the ideal candidate to provide stability and experience on the second pairing. However, questions lingered about how much of an upgrade he would represent over the Oilers' existing options, namely Cody Ceci, Brett Kulak, or Vincent Desharnais.

While Tanev's addition would undoubtedly bolster the Oilers' defensive depth, the potential impact of such a trade remained a topic of debate among fans and analysts alike. Would Tanev's presence be enough to elevate the Oilers' blue line to championship caliber status, or would the team be better served by exploring other avenues to address their defensive needs?

NEXT. NEXT. 5 things to know about Oilers new signing Connor Ungar. dark

In the end, the trade deadline passed without any movement on the Tanev front, leaving both Oilers and Flames fans to grapple with the what-ifs and hypotheticals. While the rivalry between the two Alberta teams will undoubtedly continue to simmer, the potential for a blockbuster trade involving a key player like Tanev served as a reminder of the ever-changing landscape of the NHL and the unpredictability of the trade deadline frenzy.

feed

Next