Just 15 regular season games into his career with the Edmonton Oilers, defenceman Jake Walman signed a massive contract extension worth $7 million per season for seven years.
Now, just 11 games into that new contract, there seems to be a level of buyer's remorse from both parties. General manager Stan Bowman clearly thought that Walman would be a key piece of their blueline moving forward but with him now being a consistent healthy scratch by new head coach Mike Babcock, this is not the case.
This clear disconnect has fueled plenty of speculation about his future in an Oilers uniform with trade rumours swirling around.
Walman trade rumours
The reasons that the trade speculation exists appears endless. He has been a healthy scratch, he has struggled to gain the trust of his new head coach and given the current cap situation in the league, his cap hit is manageable. As well, there are multiple teams like the Chicago Blackhawks and Toronto Maple Leafs who appear to be in the market for a player like Walman.
However, his name has not specifically been mentioned in trade rumours, in fact, multiple NHL insiders seem to be throwing cold water on them. David Pagnotta of the Fourth Period says the Oilers have no interest in trading Walman, despite a lot of recent fan noise. Pierre LeBrun said on Insider Trading "Jake Walman, whose been mostly a healthy scratch, has been hard for him to regain the trust of Babcock. He will regain his footing eventually, they have faith in him."
We will have to wait and see if LeBrun is right and if Walman can find a way to bounce back from this. Given the coach's history, once you end up on Babcock's bad side, it is extremely hard to come back from it and find a way out of the dog house. This could easily devolve into a war of attrition for either side.
Walman's struggles this season
Despite being a puck moving defender, Walman has notched just one assist in 11 games this season and has a +/- of -8. On the surface, this looks like he is struggling mightily however, his underlying numbers paint a much more optimistic picture.
When assessing Walman's play, it is important to look into his analytics. Walman sits last amongst Oilers defencemen with a 20.82% goal share at even strength. However, his 50.21% fenwick for percentage and 45.83% expected goals share put him third and fourth among Oilers defenders, respectively.
It is clear that he is struggling to score and defend but the positive fenwick and his relative ranking in xGF indicates that he may be suffering from poor puck luck. It indicates that the process is trending positively and that he may just need more time and opportunity to turn his numbers around.
Despite this, the Oilers new bench boss clearly does not have the time for the 30 year old left-handed defender. Even when Walman has been in the lineup, he has averaged just 14:15 of time on ice and has not dressed for a game since November 5th against the Anaheim Ducks. He has also been used sparingly on special teams units.
It is ultimately a results based business and if Babcock does not feel he can trust him, so be it. Can the Oilers afford to just keep him in the press box? That is the $7 million question and one that should be answered sooner rather than later for all involved.
