Skip to main content

Defensive battles cost the Edmonton Oilers against the Tampa Bay Lightning

The Edmonton Oilers' winning run ended on Thursday night against the Tampa Bay Lightning.
ByNoah Guttman
Nov 19, 2026; Tampa, Florida, USA;  Tampa Bay Lightning center Brayden Point (21) passes the puck against Edmonton Oilers defenseman Evan Bouchard (2) and right wing Vasily Podkolzin (92) during the third period at Benchmark International Arena.  Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images
Nov 19, 2026; Tampa, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Lightning center Brayden Point (21) passes the puck against Edmonton Oilers defenseman Evan Bouchard (2) and right wing Vasily Podkolzin (92) during the third period at Benchmark International Arena. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

At least the Edmonton Oilers have been able to avoid getting shut out to start the season?

After the Oilers' Thursday night contest against the Tampa Bay Lightning, which ended in a 3-1 loss, that is now the only season-long streak that they have going for them; Connor McDavid could not extend his point streak to open the season beyond 23 contests.

Here's where things went right, wrong, and devastatingly wrong for the Oilers on Thursday night.

Zone possession and entry breaks Edmonton's efforts to create offensive opportunities

There were at least a handful of instances where Tampa Bay was able to hold Edmonton in their own end and create offensive zone possessions lasting at least 30 seconds. One of those opportunities also led to Tampa Bay's opening goal of the game, which was scored by defenseman John Carlson.

In that regard, Edmonton did well to rally around goaltender Devon Levi and help get the puck out of danger. But the Lightning also maintained a strong net-front presence on both ends of the ice; here, they were able to turn back a good handful of those opportunities and maintain a net-front presence.

Another issue in this regard that plagued the Oilers were the zone rushes. While Edmonton was able to generate some success in terms of odd-number rushes, Tampa Bay did so to an equal degree of effectiveness. Early in the third period, the Lightning were able to create a rush attempt off the opening faceoff, one that ultimately ended in a scoring chance. Besides that, a lot of the rush opportunities conceded by the Oilers took the form of offensive zone turnovers, missed scoring chances, and stretch passes.

A bounce back game of sorts for Mathieu Joseph

Mathieu Joseph tends to play quite well at Benchmark International Arena (formerly Amalie Arena). That statement remains true when considering the fact that he used to play for the Lightning.

A few years ago, while a member of the Ottawa Senators, Joseph turned a five-on-three penalty kill into a short-handed rush and a 2-1 lead for the Sens. Oh, and Ottawa was getting outshot 23-5 before the goal.

On Thursday night, for the Oilers, Joseph had a short-handed breakaway that fell short only because of possession. He ended up recording a shot on goal, a pair of takeaways, and three hits by the end of the game. It is worth noting that he had a high-quality scoring chance midway through the third period off a rush attempt, but the shot was not on target.

Even then, Joseph's efforts in that regard stood out with ease, given that the Lightning were generally capable of stopping the Oilers' breakaway attempts or forcing a pass. Though the latter would sometimes end with the Oilers gaining a numerical advantage in the offensive end, the Lightning got right to the puck and sometimes did so with superior numbers.

Oilers defense puts on another showcase, but so does Tampa's

The Lightning might be the better team in terms of total shots on goal, but it didn't seem like it for a good portion of the contest. Not only did the Oilers keep the Lightning from recording a shot on goal for the first 11 minutes of the game, but they also handed them their lowest first-period count for that metric to start the season.

On top of that, the Oilers' defensive play was able to win the puck back and create offensive opportunities. One such opportunity came in the first period when Leon Draisaitl attempted to bring the puck out of the Edmonton zone and forced a holding penalty against Brayden Point.

That said, Edmonton did not have an answer for the Tampa Bay defense, which did quite well when it came to getting scoring from their top pairings. Carlson, who is on pace for a career-high in points, managed to score Tampa's first goal from the blue line. Meanwhile, Erik Cernak added an assist of his own on the insurance goal, which was scored by Ilya Mikheyev.

Ultimately, it would be defenseman Shakir Mukhamadullin that gave Edmonton some life in this contest. Though the Oilers' only goal of the game was ultimately credited to forward Colton Dach, Mukhamadullin still got credit for the goal via an assist.

But even with the above defensive contributions in mind, an Oilers defense that is capable of supporting its superstar forward cast could not do so to the same degree as Tampa's.

How to describe the straw that broke the camel's back?

I don't think I would blame Levi for Tampa Bay's third goal, which was scored by Nikita Kucherov.

From what I saw on the broadcast, it seemed Levi did well enough to keep Kucherov's shot from going into his net. Though the puck's momentum post-save could have carried it in, it seemed that it was slowing down enough to stay out.

What really hurt the Oilers there was whatever Mattias Ekholm was thinking in that moment. He was right to try and keep the puck out of danger, but shooting it onto the back of your goaltender's leg is never a good idea.

The bad news for Ekholm was that said shot attempt had enough momentum even off the deflection to go into the net.

What's next?

The Oilers will get a day off before contesting a Saturday 1:00 p.m. matinee against the Carolina Hurricanes. That game will be the first leg of a back-to-back, one that will wrap up the team's six-game road trip.

Add us as a preferred source on Google