4) Darnell Nurse
The injury to McDavid is a major setback for the Oilers, but it opens the door for the rest of the lineup to elevate their game. One player who needs to step up immediately is defenceman Darnell Nurse, an alternate captain whose presence on the ice can make a critical difference. Nurse now faces the dual challenge of anchoring the defence and setting the tone as a leader. With McDavid out, Nurse’s influence will be key in helping Edmonton stay competitive and resilient during this stretch.
Nurse’s role on defence will be under the microscope, as the Oilers work to compensate for the expected dip in scoring without their superstar forward. Keeping the puck out of their own net has now become a top priority, and Nurse will need to lead by example in tightening up Edmonton’s defensive play. His responsibility is not just to shut down opposing forwards, but also to ensure the entire defensive unit is working cohesively. Strong positioning, shot-blocking, and physical play will be essential as the Oilers strive to minimize mistakes and prevent costly goals in McDavid’s absence.
If Nurse can embrace this expanded role and rally the defensive group around him, it could make a significant difference in Edmonton's ability to withstand McDavid’s absence. His leadership, both in action and attitude, will be crucial for a team that needs everyone stepping up to fill the void. This is an opportunity for Nurse to show his value as more than just a dependable blue liner — it’s a chance for him to prove he can be the rock Edmonton leans on through adversity, setting the stage for a stronger, more cohesive team when McDavid returns.
McDavid’s presence on the ice is irreplaceable, and his absence will undoubtedly be felt by the Oilers. However, this challenging period offers a chance for the rest of the roster to showcase their resilience and depth. By stepping up as a team — whether through increased scoring contributions, defensive fortitude, or timely goaltending — the Oilers have the pieces to hold their ground and keep pace in the standings until their captain’s return.
If each player can seize the opportunity to elevate their game, the Oilers will not only manage this early-season setback but potentially come back stronger with a more unified roster. A successful response to McDavid’s absence will demonstrate that Edmonton is more than just a one-man team and will reinforce their determination to contend for a championship.