Analyzing 3 crucial rookie draft mistakes by the Oilers since 2010

3 of 4

The Edmonton Oilers are on a determined quest to claim their first Stanley Cup victory since the early 1990s. With their sights set on success, the team recognizes the need for strategic lineup adjustments to transform their dreams into reality. Exploring trade opportunities and free agency avenues, the Oilers are actively seeking ways to enhance their roster. However, navigating the constraints of a limited salary cap poses a significant challenge, requiring General Manager Ken Holland to employ more than mere sleights of hand to effect substantial changes.

The Oilers Have Made Some Mistakes

The year’s NHL Rookie Draft further complicated matters for the Oilers, who find themselves armed with only a second-round pick. In the midst of the salary cap era, where trading contracts necessitate the inclusion of valuable assets or early draft picks to sweeten the deal, the team faces a complex landscape.

This year’s draft marked a rarity for the Oilers as they lack a first-round selection, a circumstance unseen since 2006. While the organization acknowledges past draft missteps, it is essential to recognize its triumphs and astute acquisitions.

The challenge of assessing the adaptability of young players to the professional level remains a perennial struggle. Unless a team secures an extraordinary talent akin to McDavid, Matthews, Patrick Kane, Crosby, or Ovechkin, it is arduous to predict how these budding athletes will adjust. The journey to the pros is often accompanied by challenges and growing pains, with some young talents facing difficulty recovering from early setbacks.

As the Edmonton Oilers pursue their Stanley Cup aspirations, they must confront these multifaceted dynamics, aiming to strike the perfect balance between astute acquisitions, developmental strategies, and the quest for greatness on the ice.

EDMONTON, AB – OCTOBER 27: Nail Yakupov #10 of the Edmonton Oilers celebrates after scoring his team’s second goal against the Montreal Canadiens during an NHL game at Rexall Place on October 27, 2014 in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. (Photo by Derek Leung/Getty Images) /

Nail Yakupov (2012) – 1st overall pick

The 2012 NHL Rookie Draft became a subject of heated debate and frustration among hockey fans worldwide. The Edmonton Oilers, much to the dismay of many, found themselves bestowed with the first overall pick for an unprecedented third consecutive year. This remarkable stroke of luck not only stirred controversy but also raised questions about the fairness of the draft system and the team’s ability to capitalize on their advantageous position.

No other team in NHL history had ever secured the first overall pick in the draft for three consecutive years. This extraordinary feat seemed almost surreal, leaving many fans bewildered and skeptical. With the 2010 and 2011 drafts already delivering highly touted talents in Taylor Hall and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins respectively, the Oilers were handed another opportunity to add a potential superstar to their roster.

In hindsight, it is essential to evaluate the outcomes of the Oilers’ three consecutive first-overall picks. While Taylor Hall showcased flashes of brilliance during his time with the Oilers, he was eventually traded to the New Jersey Devils in 2016. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins has been a steady contributor to the team, but questions remain about whether he has lived up to the lofty expectations of a first-overall selection. The third pick in the 2012 draft, Nail Yakupov, struggled to make a lasting impact in Edmonton and eventually left the NHL to continue his career overseas.

Nail Yakupov, selected as the Oilers’ third consecutive first-overall pick, failed to live up to the lofty expectations placed upon him. Despite showing initial promise, his tenure in Edmonton was marred by inconsistent performance and an inability to find his stride. Yakupov’s struggles mirrored the organization’s wider issues, exacerbating the sense of missed opportunity and the growing frustration among fans.

The Edmonton Oilers’ inability to convert three consecutive first-overall picks into sustained success represents a missed opportunity and a significant disappointment for the organization and its fans. The failure of Nail Yakupov further highlighted the larger systemic issues within the team.

ELMONT, NEW YORK – NOVEMBER 23: Jesse Puljujarvi #13 of the Edmonton Oilers skates against the New York Islanders at the UBS Arena on November 23, 2022 in Elmont, New York. (Photo by Bruce Bennett/Getty Images) /

Jesse Puljujarvi (2016) – 4th overall pick

The Edmonton Oilers struck gold in the previous draft, securing the highly coveted generational talent, Connor McDavid. With McDavid as the centrepiece of their roster, the team now faced the crucial task of assembling a supporting cast to maximize his extraordinary abilities and propel the Oilers to sustained success.

Connor McDavid’s arrival in Edmonton brought a renewed sense of hope and excitement. As a player widely regarded as a generational talent, his presence alone had the potential to transform the Oilers’ fortunes. The organization understood the magnitude of having such a remarkable player and recognized the need to build a team that could fully capitalize on McDavid’s unique skill set.

The Edmonton Oilers’ enthusiasm and anticipation reached its peak during the draft when they found themselves in a favourable position to select Jesse Puljujarvi, a highly regarded prospect from Finland. Puljujarvi, who was initially projected to be chosen within the top three picks, unexpectedly slipped to the fourth spot. Seizing the opportunity, the Oilers swiftly made the decision to select him. However, in retrospect, this draft choice marked a pivotal moment where the team’s fortunes took an unexpected turn.

Jesse Puljujarvi entered the draft with immense hype and high expectations. As a standout prospect from Finland, his size, skill set, and scoring ability made him a highly coveted player. The Oilers, enticed by Puljujarvi’s potential, saw an opportunity to secure a dynamic forward who could complement their burgeoning core, led by Connor McDavid.

Despite the initial optimism surrounding Puljujarvi, his transition to the NHL did not unfold as anticipated. The young forward struggled to find his footing and establish consistent production at the professional level. As the Oilers’ expectations remained high, Puljujarvi’s performance fell short, leading to frustration and a sense of unfulfilled potential.

Puljujarvi’s struggles had a profound impact on the team’s overall dynamics. The Oilers’ management, coaching staff, and players grappled with the challenge of integrating a developing player into their lineup while also contending for success. The pressure to succeed, combined with Puljujarvi’s difficulties, created a discordant atmosphere that hindered the team’s progress and undermined their aspirations.

SEATTLE, WASHINGTON – MARCH 18: Kailer Yamamoto #56 of the Edmonton Oilers celebrates his goal against the Seattle Kraken during the first period at Climate Pledge Arena on March 18, 2023 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Steph Chambers/Getty Images) /

Kailer Yamamoto (2017) – 22nd overall pick

Kailer Yamamoto, a beloved figure among many hockey fans, embarked on his journey with the Edmonton Oilers filled with high hopes and expectations. However, despite their genuine affection for Yamamoto, his tenure with the team has been marred by difficulties and a lack of fruitful results.

Yamamoto’s early days with the Oilers showcased his immense potential and promise. The diminutive forward brought a spark of energy to the team, exhibiting exceptional speed, skill, and a tenacious playing style. His initial performances ignited excitement among fans and raised anticipation for a bright future with the team.

Unfortunately, Yamamoto’s time with the Oilers has been marked by inconsistency. While he has shown flashes of brilliance, he has also experienced prolonged scoring droughts and difficulty finding sustained success. This inconsistency has left fans and the organization yearning for more from the talented forward.

The Oilers’ lineup instability over the years has also affected Yamamoto’s development. With frequent changes in linemates and limited stability in his role, finding consistent chemistry and building a rapport with teammates has proven challenging. These factors have hindered his ability to fully showcase his skills and reach his potential.

Kailer Yamamoto’s journey with the Edmonton Oilers has been a challenging one, characterized by inconsistencies and unfulfilled potential. We witnessed Yammer’s last game in an Oilers jersey as the team tries to shed some money away to improve the team this season.

Home / Oilers News