Edmonton Oilers Weekly Oil Drop Mail Bag #2: Trades and Fans

Mail Bag Question #1: Brent Burns or Dustin Byfuglien

Facebook User Cory Hoffman gave us a rather interesting question regarding two defenders.

"“Burnsy or Big Buff? To trade the first round pick, and if so, for who?"

Thanks for your question, Cory! This was an interesting question for me. If I had to choose, and this is saying that both could likely occur, I would want Brent Burns.

First off, the guy’s Chewbacca style is fantastic; who wouldn’t want a guy like Burnsy on your team? He’s fun-loving and obviously a great team player. He even has connections to the team, as Todd McLellan coached him during his time in San Jose.

He’s also a big guy, and I mean BIG. 6-foot-5, 230 pounds. The Oilers lack size, and that is exactly what Burns can provide. Big Buff’s a big guy, too, but Burns can throw his weight around, is familiar with McLellan and is a proven leader.

As for which one is more realistic? I think the Oilers go for Big Buff. He’s going to be a UFA and it’s not likely that Winnipeg resigns him. He would bring speed, strength and size to the Oilers lineup; not to mention that he has a Stanley Cup championship under his belt. Plus, as a free agent, the Oilers won’t have to give up anything up for him.

Plus, the Sharks aren’t likely to trade away Burns unless our offer is legitimately out of this world.

Next: Mail Bag Question #2