Pucks And Bucks: The Shea Weber Offer Sheet

Be it Nashville, or Philadelphia, Shea Weber is about to get paid. Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-US PRESSWIRE

In less than a week, current Predators captain Shea Weber just might become a member of the Philadelphia Flyers.

The Flyers offered Weber a staggering 14 year, $100M+ contract (certain outlets report $110M or more), which Weber agreed to. The Predators have seven days to match the number and retain Shea Weber. If they elect not to, Weber will become a Philadelphia Flyer likely for the remainder of his career. The Predators would receive Phiadelphia’s first round draft picks from 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016.

This is the exact circumstance that occurred in 2007 when the Oilers offered Thomas Vanek a seven year, $52M deal.  The Sabres matched Vanek’s deal, and I would be surprised if Nashville didn’t match Weber’s.

I’ve heard a few different accounts of how a move like this would ‘put Edmonton over the hump’, and all I’ve done is gripe about how the team needs to grab another defenceman at nearly all costs.  Shouldn’t this make me happy?

A move like this would make the Oilers look pretty good during the season in the first year.  But what about after the first year?

MORE THINKING

I’ve thought about this from Philadelphia’s perspective for a day or so now.  If Nashville doesn’t match the Weber offer sheet, Philly gets a cornerstone defenceman for the next fourteen (or so) years.  They’d give up their next four first round picks, which would probably start at 18th overall (if they flame out in the playoffs), but could easily wind up in the early or mid twenties.  Could the Flyers survive?

The shortest answer I can think of is, well, yes.  Don’t get me wrong, Philadelphia will miss those first round picks, but not nearly as much if they were the Oilers.

If you want to get the good groceries, you’ve got to shop where the good groceries are.  Shea Weber is good, really good groceries.

If you take the heavier of the reported numbers, Shea Weber’s cap hit works out to about $8M (really, what’s a few hundred thousand dollars between friends?) a year over the lifetime of that 14-year deal.  That’s a lot of doughnuts.  Consider the fact that  that some guys named Jordan Eberle and Taylor Hall will be in line for deals next year.  Oh sure, the Khabibulin deal (mercifully) comes off the books, but you’d have to think that both Hall and Eberle’s deals will likely run in the 5M range.  Keeping Ladislav Smid in the fold?  What about Jeff Petry in 2 years?  Speaking of two years, there’s RNH, and eventually Yakupov…  you get where I’m going with this.

Even if Shea Weber were to agree to an offer sheet with the Oilers, the sheer volume of this contract compiled with the four first round picks make it a huge gamble that’s simply too rich for my liking.  If Dubnyk plays 60 games and somehow wins 34 of them, and secondary scoring came from the bottom six, and Shea Weber put everyone on his back and marched triumphantly into the promised land, it might be worth it.

But understand, I’m a bit shy to the idea.  As of this moment, I’m not in any way, shape or fashion convinced that the Oilers are a playoff team.  Could they be with Shea Weber?  Of course.  Can’t stress enough how much this team needs another defenceman, and Weber would be the tonic.

But what if it doesn’t work out right?  The thought of losing first round picks each year over the next four, compiled with a fourteen year albatross of a contract does absolutely nothing for me.

Would you offer Shea Weber a fourteen year deal at nearly $8M a year?

Follow Oil On Whyte on the Twitters.

Jeff – @OilOnWhyte

Grant- @RealOilFan

Samson – @threwittki

Ian – @ibleedoil

Jonathan – @jonrmcleod

Marcus – @SportMajor

Keegan – @KeeganWiebe

Troy – @heavyoilcountry

Check out the Oilers Army!

Click Here to visit our NHL main page “Too Many Men” – Fansided’s Hockey Home on the Internets

Topics: Defence, Shea Weber

Want more from Oil On Whyte?  
Subscribe to FanSided Daily for your morning fix. Enter your email and stay in the know.
  • OilerTrades

    i dont know why you keep saying we need those 1st rounders more than philly does. our offense is more or less fine. with explosive fire power. sure we dont have size, but we are a force to be reckoned with. on d if we have weber. that guy is playing half the game every game, so for half the game we are getting good solid d. the rest, we have mediocre. if we added weber to our already dynamic offense, theres no doubt in my mind that we would be a playoff team

    • OilOnWhyte

      @OilerTrades Although offence is one of this team’s finer points, I’m a bit apprehensive to call anything “explosive”, what with the missing playoffs for six consecutive years and the like. If the team swings a deal that forsakes the nest 4 first round picks, and we see a repeat performance of the last six years, are you OK donating a top 10 pick to Nashville?

TEAMFeed More Oilers news from the Fansided Network

Hot on the Web From golf.com