Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-US PRESSWIRE

Devan Dubnyk's New Contract And Comparables

I believe they're beginning to get the big picture. Screenshot courtesy

I’ve been imploring this club to give the reins of the starting goaltending position to Devan Dubnyk for some time now.  With Dubnyk’s new two year $7M contract, it appears that day might have come.  (Do not look at the $3.75M backup during this exercise, it will serve you no purpose).

Assuming Dubnyk’s near 450% raise will get him the lion’s share of the starts, what can we expect?  What are his comparables?

Let’s take a look at some numbers, quick and dirty.

Looking at Devan Dubnyk’s NHL statistics page from 2011-12, we can point out a few obvious stats.  Dubnyk finished with a record of 20-20-3.  His save percentage clocked in at .914, his GAA finished at 2.67, and he had a pair of shutouts to go with those numbers.

Who are Dubnyk’s comparables?  Bonus:  these charts get BIG when you click them.

Screenshot courtesy Click to enlarge.

Dubnyk’s best time on ice 2011-12 comparable was Nicklas Backstrom of the Minnesota Wild.  Backstrom’s 2012-13 cap hit?  $6M.  Urp.  Backstrom finished with similar numbers to Dubnyk with a little more than one game’s less time on ice.  Backstrom had a .919 SV% versus Dubnyk’s .914.  Backstrom had two more shutouts, and a .25 less GAA.  Dubnyk had one more win.  Putting Dubnyk next to a six million dollar deal makes $3.5M look awfully good.

How about wins?

Backstrom is again a comparable, but so is Evgeni Nabokov of the Islanders.  Dubnyk started in 42 of his 47 GP last year, while Nabokov started 41 of 42.  Both Nabokov and Dubnyk have identical save percentages and shutouts, while Dubnyk has about 275 more minutes on the ice.  Backstrom’s cap hit next year is 6M, while Nabakov’s cap hit in 2012-13 is 2.75M.  I like Dubnyk’s hit over both these guys.

Finally, how about saves?

This one’s good for a few laughs.  The highlighted column is actual saves.  Two columns to the left is shots.  Devan Dubnyk played in ten fewer games than Detroit’s Jimmy Howard (’12-’13 cap: 2.25M), yet Howard faced only 92 more shots.  Chicago’s Corey Crawford (’12-’13 cap: 2.667M) also played in ten more games than Dubnyk, with a shot differential of just 127.    Notice Steve Mason (’12-’13 cap: 2.9M) had exactly 50 less saves than Dubnyk and 25 fewer shots.  It’s well recorded that Mason didn’t have a great season for various reasons (seriously, equipment issues?)

Dubnyk is 26, and he’s starting the contract that will likely define the rest of his career.  I don’t think anyone thought Dubnyk would be earning north of $3M in the next couple of years (myself included), but it doesn’t look at all outrageous when stuck next to his counterparts.

What does Dubnyk need to do in order for him to ‘earn’ this contract?

Follow Oil On Whyte on the Twitters.

Jeff – @OilOnWhyte

Grant- @RealOilFan

Samson – @threwittki

Ian – @ibleedoil

Jonathan – @jonrmcleod

Marcus – @SportMajor

Keegan – @KeeganWiebe

Troy – @heavyoilcountry

Check out the Oilers Army!

Click Here to visit our NHL main page “Too Many Men” – Fansided’s Hockey Home on the Internets

Tags: Devan Dubnyk Goaltending


    You beat me to the punch on this blog idea … ; )
    Considering the horrendous November/December and the less than adequate defence, I felt as though Dubnyk had a good season, Dubnyk’s January and beyond were great, when looking at what he had in front of him.
    I have no problem with the contract. It shows a lot of faith by Oilers management. The contract clearly puts Dubnyk into the role of “your job to lose”. I think Dubnyk will live up to the contract within the first year of the deal. I cannot put numbers on what makes this a contract that Dubnyk’s lives up to, too many variables. I will let the season, as each month passes, be my gauge on whether or not Dubnyk is earning his coin. What I can say, with regards to stats, is that there must be signs of improvement. A better than .500 winning percentage. A slightly higher save pct. A slightly lower goals against.

    • OilOnWhyte

       @STAZE When I first saw the cap hit, I freaked a little.  If it took a $7M deal to get him in full time, then I guess we’ve got to have it.  
      If the Oilers are in the playoff race, I think he’ll be OK.  My personal thought?  24 wins would be nice.  

      • STAZE

         @OilOnWhyte I think the playoff race is very reasonable and some what expected by myself. I see the Oil finishing in and around 10th to 12th and as few as 6 points out of the playoffs.
        The key, injuries. Sure, the Oilers will have their fair share. Hopefully lengthy injuries to players such as Hall, RNH, Whitney (like last season) do not occur this season.

        • OilOnWhyte

           @STAZE Need one more iron in the fire as far as defence is concerned.  I’m about 90% happy with the forwards.  One more defenceman that’s of second line quality, and this team has a legitimate shot at the playoffs.