Three From The Field: Prospective Free Agent Defencemen

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

Gervais should come cheaply. Mandatory Credit: Kevin Hoffman-US PRESSWIRE

Let’s start off with…


2011-12 Team:  Tampa Bay Lightning, will be UFA on July 1st

Age:  27

Salary:  $525,000, will be UFA on July 1st

Numbers:  44 GP, 4-5-9, 8 PIM, -3 +/-


Gervais is an ideal 5-6 kind of guy. Before you say that this team doesn’t need any more 5/6 kinds of guys, please recall not long ago how Cam Barker was being touted as a top four defenceman, and how Taylor Chorney and Colten Teubert were on a pair together.

You can never, ever have too many defencemen.

He comes at the right price (he’s making 525K this year in Tampa), he’ll be 28 when the 2012-13 season begins, and he’s playing about 16 minutes a night as of this sentence.  Gervais isn’t going to light it up on the score sheet, but I’m going to go ahead and say that when this team dealt Tom Gilbert last week that offence from the defence really wasn’t on their mind.  The Lightning are on the outside of the playoff race looking in, and Gervais is second in +/- on the regulars.  Plus minus is a funny stat, but when you consider that Gervais has nine points this year (and his plus minus isn’t a disaster on Tampa), I think it’s worth pointing out.  If he’s available come July 1st, I’d see what 8-900K for two years would do to his spirits.

Then again, he might see what Andy Sutton is making and demand twice that.

Coveted. Mandatory Credit: Jason O. Watson-US PRESSWIRE


2011-12 Team:  Calgary Flames, will be UFA on July 1st

Age:  33

Salary:  $1M

Numbers:  62 GP, 2-9-11, 24 PIM, -6 +/-


Yes, please.  Just grab your things, and move up a few hundred kilometres.  I’ll be outside with a cake.  You can’t miss it.

Hannan is a rarity in the land of Feaster, and that is his no-movement clause is only for this year.  He’ll become an unrestricted free agent if he makes it to July 1st, to which the Oilers should be on the phone with his agent throwing numbers his way. Hannan is well capable of playing over twenty minutes per game (he played almost 23 in Calgary’s loss to the Stars).  Ideally he’d be a middle pairing guy, but I don’t think I’d have a heart attack if he found himself on the top line now and again.  He’s the sixth highest paid defenceman on the Flames roster (Chris Butler is making more) and he’s pulling twenty minutes plus per night.  I keep finding myself coming back to the Andy Sutton deal, and now I’m thinking that Hannan would be a nice fit.  Would $2M be out of the question for two years?  On a team that sees Nikolai Khabibulin make nearly $4M over the past three seasons, it’s easy to slam your hands on a desk and shout to the sky.  I wanted him on the Oilers last year, and this year is no different.  $2M a year for two years, come play.

Finally, a name some of you had expressed interest in acquiring via trade route this year…

NO PARKING. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-US PRESSWIRE


2011-12 Team:  Dallas Stars, will be RFA on July 1st

Age:  26

Salary:  $1M

Numbers:  50 GP, 0-1-1, 35 PIM, -2 (+/-)


Fistric is another 5/6 guy that I’d love to see on the Oilers for the right price.  He’s Edmonton born, and can skate faster than Cam Barker for less money.  Fistric is an RFA, which requires a little bit more thought other than running up to a guy’s agent and handing him a suitcase full of money seeing if he bites.  If July 1st comes and the Stars make an offer, there’s always a chance that Fistric goes to arbitration.  This tends to get a little bit messy, and if it ends up like the Clarke MacArthur fiasco did a few years back, it could make Fistric end up a UFA.  This could bode well for the Oilers, so a ‘wait-and-see’ methodology could work the best.

Fistric is a guy I would be willing to make a three year offer on.  You know what you’re getting, and scoring isn’t it.  Fistric has only 35 penalty minutes in 50 games played this year.  He was suspended three games earlier this year for a head hit to the Islanders’ Nino Neiderreiter, but if I can get 60 games of this a year, I’d like it…

That’s Bobby Ryan who is gleefully being placed into the boards from an excitable Mark Fistric.  Fistric plays ball hockey in Edmonton.  Would he like to play ice hockey as well?

Would be happy to trade a player or a pick in order to acquire the rights of Fistric from Dallas.  1M isn’t bad for a 5/6 guy, but again, Sutton.  Would $4M over 3 years be enough to bring Fistric home full time?


There you have it.  Three guys that will be either UFA or RFA come July 1st.  If the Oilers could land Fistric and Hannan, I’d be absolutely thrilled.  Fistric and Gervais would be OK too.  Heck, guys that can play on the defence and be dependable for 60-70 games a season would be a great start.  If this team could pull two of these three guys and maintain the roster they have now, playoffs are a lot, lot closer than anyone dares think. Winning is important.  Even if ‘the rebuild’ hasn’t ended yet, showing your young guns that you’d like to win is before their entry level contracts are over might be something you’d be interested in doing.

Have your say:  What prospective free agent defenceman (UFA or RFA) do you think the Oilers have a legit chance at acquiring this summer?  How much would you be willing to spend?

Follow Oil On Whyte on the Twitters.

Jeff – @OilOnWhyte

Grant- @RealOilFan

Samson – @threwittki

Ian – @ibleedoil

Become a fan on our Facebook page too!

Click Here to visit our NHL main page “Too Many Men” – Fansided’s Hockey Home on the Internets

Use your ← → (arrows) to browse

  • Oil_Drop

    @OilOnWhyte I’m all in for Fistric, if for no other reason that he pounds the hell out the Oilers every time they play the Stars.

  • OilBaron

    I think we need the big fish.  It isn’t the bottom end that is the biggest concern, easiest to fill the holes.  It is the op end defenseman who can move the puck and eat minutes.

    • OilOnWhyte

      What makes you think this team can acquire a big fish?
      My second question:  What makes you think a big fish would be happy to play for a team like Edmonton?  Should this team fork over 9M a year for a guy like Weber to play here?  
      Finally, what is this team going to give up in order to get a 1D who isn’t a UFA?  Start at this year’s number one, add Gagner, probably another roster player and a prospect.  
      It might not be the ‘fix all’, but if this team gets enough duct tape to put together a defence that doesn’t leak every night, they’re in the playoffs come 2013.  

      • OilBaron

         @OilOnWhyte I’ll start with the trade, sounds good to me.  The right pieces.  This team needs help on the blue line now, not 3 years from now.
        There’s room for bottom end help.  But, if they are the only help this team is in the same position next year at this time.
        Why can’t this team acquire a big fish, and why wouldn’t a big fish want to join a young offensively gifted team?  I’m sure you don’t mean it in the usual defeatest attitude that a lot of Oilers have.  There are a limited number of these types for a reason, they are super valuable.  They play big and important minutes and they are multidimensional players.  As such you pay for them.  Do I pay 9 milion per, no.  A deal for Weber in the 10-12 year range for 65-80 million is fair.

        • OilOnWhyte

           @jayparrpearson I agree with you that the team needs help now.  I think there’s more to it than just signing a big fish.  
          How many years should a guy like Weber be willing to donate to ‘the rebuild’?  Guy is 25 right now.  Two?  Three?
          If you give him the heavy part of your numbers (12-80), he’d be making less per year than he is right now. at 7.5.  The team would have to unload the coffers to this guy.  I wouldn’t be surprised to see him get 8 to 9 M.  How many ‘elite D’ exist on the free agent front?

        • OilBaron

           @OilOnWhyte I think that Weber is part of the solution to get back in and even help draw in other talent.  Years? He will let them know.